Monday, March 04, 2019

Untold Undersea Battle?

Did a Russian Built Stealth Submarine 'Sink' a Navy Nuclear Attack Sub? Fact or fiction?
by Dave Majumdar


While diesel-electric boats are generally quieter than nuclear submarines, the U.S. Navy prefers atomic powered vessels because of their range, speed and endurance.The U.S. Navy’s global mission essentially mandates a vessel that can operate independently far from home waters for extended periods. Navies with a more localized mission can afford to operate short-range diesel-electric boats. While the Indian report may or may not be correct, this incident highlights the need to completely
replace the Los Angeles-class with Virginia-class boats as soon as possible.

Is it possible that one of New Delhi’s Russian-built  Kilo-class diesel-electric attack submarines managed to “sink” a nuclear-powered U.S. Navy  Los Angeles -class attack submarine during exercises in October 2015?

According to the Indians, the submarines were assigned to track each other down in the Bay of Bengal. “The way it happens is that the  Sindhudhvaj recorded the Hydrophonic Effect (HE) - simply put, underwater noise - of the nuclear powered submarine and managed to positively identify it before locking on to it. Being an exercise what did not happen was the firing,” an Indian naval officer  told India Today . The Indian vessel then “sank” USS  City of Corpus Christi  using 533mm
torpedoes.

If the Indian description of the events is correct, it would be a bright spot in an otherwise dismal record for New Delhi’s undersea force.

In recent years, the woefully neglected Indian submarine fleet has suffered numerous calamities. Submarines have run aground, caught fire and even sunk due to acombination of underinvestment, negligence and corruption. Perhaps the worst incident was when INS  Sindhurakshak sank when at harbor in Mumbai after a series ofexplosions in the forward torpedo bay, killing eighteen sailors.

Nonetheless, it’s not a huge surprise that a  Russian-built Kilo would be able to defeat a  Los Angeles -class attack boat. The  Los Angeles -class is a dated designthat is slowly being replaced by the newer and exponentially quieter  Virginia-class submarine. However, it must be noted that we do not know the rules of engagementor parameters that the sides had agreed to. Furthermore, it must be noted there is the possibility of exaggeration.

But the basic facts are that the  Kilo is an extremely quiet and very capable submarine owing to its diesel-electric propulsion system. Running on electrical power while submerged, diesel-electric boats have been described as “a hole in the water” and are a vexing problem for the U.S. Navy. Developing ways to counter such vessels is a high-priority for Washington as many potential adversaries like China and Iran operate such submarines.

While diesel-electric boats are generally quieter than nuclear submarines, the U.S. Navy prefers atomic powered vessels because of their range, speed and endurance. The U.S. Navy’s global mission essentially mandates a vessel that can operate independently far from home waters for extended periods. Navies with a more localizedmission can afford to operate short-range diesel-electric boats.

While the Indian report may or may not be correct, this incident highlights the need to completely replace the  Los Angeles -class with  Virginia-class boats as soon as possible.

The Virginia-class is orders of magnitude quieter and offers far better sensors and carries more weapons. The newer vessels are far more effective against threats like the  Kilo than their  Los Angeles -class predecessors. Buying as many  Virginias as possible becomes especially important as more and more potential adversaries procure advanced diesel-electric boats like the  Kilo or the even more capable  Russian-built Amur.




ALSO CHECK OUT MY 2 BOOKS “THE SHAITAN” & “HOBO HANDBOOK: MEMOIRS OF A HOMELESS POET IN NEW YORK” SOLD AT THESE LOCATIONS:
https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/655627

http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/hobo-handbook-daniel-canada/1124340542?ean=2940153669205


They are not being sold on Amazon.com at this time.

To view a few sample pages or to purchase the books visit:

https://smashwords.com/books/view/573076  (Note: You must 1st remove “adult content” filter from top right hand corner of Smashword page to access the books, by clicking the “Adult Content” button before searching for the titles titles in search field).

If you want to view my Smashwords Author Profile visit:


You can also check out the comments I will be posting on these social media sites:

My Twitter account: https://twitter.com/lordlumiel
If you wish to shoot me a personal note, this is my email address: lordlumiel@yahoo.com
I’d love to hear from you!
-Daniel Canada aka Obsidian